Town government · Suffolk County, NY

Shelter Island's money: where it comes from and where it goes

This page shows where Town of Shelter Island gets its money and where it goes, in its latest recorded fiscal year, which ended December 31, 2025. It covers Town of Shelter Island itself; the other governments that serve the same area are separate.

Source: New York State Comptroller, Financial Data for Local Governments, fiscal year 2025.

How much does Shelter Island spend each year?
In its fiscal year that ended December 31, 2025, Shelter Island spent $21.1 million.

Where does Shelter Island's money come from?
In its fiscal year that ended December 31, 2025, the largest sources of Shelter Island's $20.8 million in revenue were property tax ($12.8 million, 62%), other taxes ($2.9 million, 14%) and fees for services ($2.0 million, 9.4%).

How much of Shelter Island's revenue is property tax?
In its fiscal year that ended December 31, 2025, property tax was $12.8 million, or 62% of Shelter Island's $20.8 million in revenue.

Shelter Island spends $19 of every $100 on police, fire, courts and jails, 3 times what a typical town or township its size spends. It spent $21.1 million and took in $20.8 million in its latest recorded year (FY2025). That fiscal year ended December 31, 2025.

Fiscal year 2025 (ended December 31, 2025), from the New York State Comptroller.

Where it comes from

Town taxes76%Fees for services9.4%Fines and other7.8%State tax money5.4%County and local tax money1.1%Federal tax money0.8%

Town taxes76%

Property tax
62%$12.8 million
Other taxes
14%$2.9 million

Fees for services9.4%

Fees for services
9.4%$2.0 million

Federal tax money0.8%

Grants from Washington, paid for by the federal taxes residents also pay.

From the federal government
0.8%$161 thousand

State tax money5.4%

Money the state passes on, paid for by the state taxes residents also pay.

From the state
5.4%$1.1 million

County and local tax money1.1%

Money passed on by the county or other local governments.

From the county and other local governments
1.1%$224 thousand

Fines and other7.8%

Interest, rents and other
7.5%$1.6 million
Fines
0.3%$58 thousand

Where it goes

Running the government and other costs40%Employee benefits (pensions, health insurance, Social Security)22%Police, fire, courts and jails19%Roads, transit and parking8.0%Water, sewer, trash and utilities6.4%All other spending5.2%

Spending by category100%

Running the government and other costs
40%$8.4 million
Employee benefits (pensions, health insurance, Social Security)
22%$4.7 million
Retirement, Social Security, health insurance and workers compensation costs that are not charged to one department. Benefits paid inside a department's own budget are counted with that department.
Police, fire, courts and jails
19%$3.9 million
Roads, transit and parking
8.0%$1.7 million
Water, sewer, trash and utilities
6.4%$1.4 million
Social services
3.0%$630 thousand
Parks, recreation and libraries
1.8%$378 thousand
Health and hospitals
0.3%$68 thousand
Environment and natural resources
<0.1%$18 thousand
Interest on debt
<0.1%$9 thousand
Earlier figures from the U.S. Census BureauFiscal year ended December 31, 2021

The U.S. Census Bureau's figures for Shelter Island, fiscal year ended December 31, 2021: U.S. Census Bureau, 2022 Census of Governments, Finance, individual unit file. The Census groups some money differently, so categories do not line up with the figures above.

Where it comes from

Town taxes86%Fees for services (garbage collection, parks and recreation)6.8%State tax money4.2%Fines and other1.5%County and local tax money1.0%Federal tax money0.5%

What stands out

33%

of Shelter Island's money comes from taxes other than property, sales and income taxes.Most U.S. townships and towns of under 10,000 people get none.

Town taxes86%

Property tax
53%$10.2 million
Other taxes
33%$6.5 million
What's in other taxesOther taxes not classified elsewhere; other licenses and 1 more
  • Other taxes not classified elsewhere$5.5 million
  • Other licenses$856 thousand
  • Public utility taxes$78 thousand

Amounts are by Census tax category.

Fees for services6.8%

Fees for services
6.8%$1.3 million
What's in fees for servicesGarbage collection; other service charges and 3 more
  • Garbage collection$633 thousand
  • Other service charges$364 thousand
  • Parks and recreation$161 thousand
  • Parking$100 thousand
  • Water$67 thousand

Amounts are by Census type of charge.

Federal tax money0.5%

Grants from Washington, paid for by the federal taxes residents also pay.

From the federal government
0.5%$103 thousand

State tax money4.2%

Money the state passes on, paid for by the state taxes residents also pay.

From the state
4.2%$805 thousand

County and local tax money1.0%

Money passed on by the county or other local governments.

From the county and other local governments
1.0%$190 thousand

Fines and other1.5%

Interest, rents and other
1.3%$251 thousand
Fines
0.2%$34 thousand

Where it goes

Running the government and other costs55%Police, fire, courts and jails20%Roads, transit and parking8.9%Water, sewer, trash and utilities8.1%Health and hospitals5.1%All other spending2.8%

What stands out

55%

of Shelter Island's spending goes to running the government and other costs.A typical U.S. township or town of under 10,000 people spends 23%.

Spending by category100%

Running the government and other costs
55%$7.5 million
What's in running the government and other costsOther and not broken out; central staff services (personnel, purchasing, technology) and 2 more
  • Other and not broken out$5.7 million
  • Central staff services (personnel, purchasing, technology)$910 thousand
  • Finance, tax collection and budgeting$615 thousand
  • Government buildings$263 thousand
Police, fire, courts and jails
20%$2.7 million
What's in police, fire, courts and jailsPolice; courts and legal services and 2 more
  • Police$2.2 million
  • Courts and legal services$260 thousand
  • Inspections and regulation$237 thousand
  • Prisons and jails$2 thousand
Roads, transit and parking
8.9%$1.2 million
What's in roads, transit and parkingRoads and highways and ports and harbors
  • Roads and highways$1.2 million
  • Ports and harbors$40 thousand
Water, sewer, trash and utilities
8.1%$1.1 million
What's in water, sewer, trash and utilitiesGarbage and solid waste; water supply and 1 more
  • Garbage and solid waste$1.0 million
  • Water supply$81 thousand
  • Sewer systems$4 thousand
Health and hospitals
5.1%$692 thousand
What's in health and hospitalsPublic health and hospitals
  • Public health$681 thousand
  • Hospitals$11 thousand
Parks, recreation and libraries
2.3%$311 thousand
What's in parks, recreation and librariesParks and recreation
  • Parks and recreation$311 thousand
Interest on debt
0.5%$66 thousand
Environment and natural resources
<0.1%$8 thousand
What's in environment and natural resourcesNatural resources, farming and conservation
  • Natural resources, farming and conservation$8 thousand
Sources and moreWhere these numbers come from and what they cover

Town of Shelter Island. New York State Comptroller, Financial Data for Local Governments, fiscal year 2025, fiscal year ended December 31, 2025. The earlier Census figures are from U.S. Census Bureau, 2022 Census of Governments, Finance, individual unit file, fiscal year ended December 31, 2021.

How these figures are counted. Revenue and spending are the New York State Comptroller's account-level reports for Shelter Island, grouped into the same categories as the Census figures. Borrowing, transfers between a government's own funds, internal service funds and pension or custodial trust funds are not counted.

Employee benefits are their own spending line: the retirement, Social Security, health insurance and workers compensation costs a government books centrally. Benefits charged inside a department's own budget (for example a sheriff's) stay with that department.

Federal and state money. Federal money that reaches Shelter Island through the State is shown here as federal aid. The Census figures count it as state aid, so the federal and state shares on the two versions do not match.

What this covers. The money of Town of Shelter Island itself. Other governments that serve the same area (the city, county, school district and state) are separate and not included. Borrowing, transfers between a government's own funds, and pension trust funds are not counted as revenue.